For anyone facing criminal charges under the Criminal Code of Canada, understanding the distinctions between indictable offences, summary conviction offences, and hybrid offences is essential. These classifications determine legal rights, court procedures, potential penalties, and strategies to protect an accused’s interests.

Here is an in-depth look at these categories and why they matter.

Why These Classifications Matter

For individuals navigating the criminal justice system, the classification of the offence they face impacts every stage of the legal process.

  1. Potential Penalties: The severity of penalties differs widely between summary conviction and indictable offences. There are also significant immigration consequences for foreign nationals (e.g., work permits or study permits). An experienced defence lawyer can work to minimize these consequences, particularly in hybrid cases where the Crown has the discretion to proceed summarily.

  2. Legal Rights: Indictable charges provide additional rights, such as the option for a jury trial and a preliminary hearing. Understanding these rights allows the accused to make informed decisions about their defence.

  3. Procedural Aspects: Limitation periods, trial processes, and the court of appeal vary depending on the offence type. These distinctions can significantly affect how a case is handled.

Summary Conviction Offences: Less Serious, But Not to Be Taken Lightly

Summary conviction offences encompass less serious crimes, but crimes that are still serious, such as:

  • Public nudity;

  • Causing a public disturbance;

  • Loitering;

  • Disturbing worship or other meetings;

  • Trespassing at night;

  • Unlawful assembly;

  • Prize fighting;

  • Being found in or permitting a gaming house;

  • Defacing currency.

While the penalties are less severe than those for indictable offences, they can still significantly impact one’s life.

Key Features of Summary Conviction Offences:

  • Limitation Period: Charges must be laid within one year of the alleged offence. In BC, the provincial Crown are responsible for laying charges. This limitation protects individuals from being prosecuted for minor incidents years after they have occurred.

  • Penalties: Maximum penalties for summary conviction offences generally include:

    • Up to two years less a day in prison

    • Fines up to $5,000

  • Streamlined Trial Process: Summary conviction cases are tried before a provincial court judge without a jury or a preliminary hearing.

  • Appeals: Appeals for summary conviction offences are heard in the Superior Court of the province, not the Court of Appeal.

Indictable Offences: The Most Serious Charges

Indictable offences represent the most severe crimes under Canadian law. These include:

  • Murder;

  • Manslaughter;

  • Terrorism;

  • Aggravated assault;

  • Fraud over $5,000;

  • Break and enter;

  • Robbery;

  • Extortion;

  • Drug trafficking;

  • Trafficking a controlled substance (e.g., heroin, fentanyl, cocaine);

  • Possession of a controlled substance for the purpose of trafficking;

  • Importing a controlled substance;

  • Exporting a controlled substance;

  • Production of a controlled substance;

  • Possession of a firearm knowing it is unauthorized;

  • Possession of a prohibited weapon, device or ammunition knowing it is unauthorized;

  • Manufacturing of a firearm;

  • Trafficking of a firearm;

  • Treason;

  • Kidnapping;

  • Various sexual offences.

The stakes are extraordinarily high, with potential penalties extending to life imprisonment in some cases.

Key Features of Indictable Offences:

  • Choice of Mode of Trial: If charged with an indictable offence, the accused has the right to choose how their case will be tried with some exceptions. There are three options:

    1. A judge-alone trial in provincial court.

    2. A judge-alone trial in superior court.

    3. A jury trial in superior court.

  • No Limitation Period: There is no statute of limitations for prosecuting indictable offences. Charges can be brought forward years—or even decades—after the alleged offence. This is not unusual in allegations of historical sexual assaults.

  • Serious Consequences: Convictions for indictable offences carry severe penalties, often including lengthy prison sentences. There may also be serious immigration consequences. An accused facing such charges should strongly consider having skilled legal representation.

  • Appeals: Appeals for convictions on indictable offences are heard by the Court of Appeal in the province where the trial took place.

Hybrid Offences: The Crown Decides

Hybrid offences are the most common charges in Canada. Parliament wrote most criminal offences in the Criminal Code with an option for the Crown to proceed by indictment or by summary conviction. The Crown’s decision is based on a number of factors such as the seriousness of the allegations, the accused’s criminal record, and the complexity of the case.

Examples of Hybrid Offences:

  • Assault;

  • Sexual assault;

  • Domestic assault;

  • Uttering threats;

  • Impaired driving;

  • Driving over 80;

  • Dangerous driving;

  • Failure to stop after an accident (hit and run);

  • Possession of controlled substances (e.g., heroin, fentanyl, etc.);

  • Careless use of a firearm;

  • Carrying a concealed weapon;

  • Unauthorized possession of a firearm;

  • Possession of a restricted or prohibited firearm with ammunition;

  • Fraud under $5,000;

  • Theft under $5,000;

  • Shoplifting;

  • Possession of stolen property under $5,000;

  • Breach of probation;

  • Breach of undertaking;

  • Breach of a court order;

  • Breach of a recognizance;

  • Public mischief;

  • Obstruction of justice;

  • Criminal harassment.

Factors Influencing the Crown’s Decision:

  1. Seriousness of Allegations: If the offence involves significant harm or aggravating factors, the Crown may elect to proceed by indictment.

  2. Criminal History: The Crown may consider an accused’s prior criminal record and history.

  3. Case Complexity: Complex cases involving extensive evidence or multiple witnesses are more likely to proceed by indictment.

  4. Public Interest and Notoriety: High-profile cases or those with significant community impact may also warrant an election to proceed by indictment.

Conclusion

Understanding the differences between indictable, summary conviction, and hybrid offences is critical for anyone charged under the Criminal Code of Canada. Each classification comes with distinct legal rights, procedural rules, and potential penalties that can call for different defence strategies.

Whether advocating for a dismissal, negotiating a reduced charge, or mounting a vigorous defence at trial, having a skilled lawyer on your side is invaluable. If you or someone you know is facing criminal charges, act immediately. Reach out to the experienced criminal defence lawyers at Filkow Law for advice.

Prev Next